074: CULPABILITY

<<First ………. <Prev ………. [Archive] ………. [Map] ………. Next> ………. Last>>

My arm feels normal again by the time our little holiday is up. It still moves a little clumsily, which is probably a sign that I’m getting too old for this shit, if one night of wrong sleep can hurt my arm for days. Or maybe it’s a lingering effect of chronostasis. No matter how many maintenance drugs you pump into a person, it’s hard for a body to recover completely from several months comatose in a chronostatic field.

I should count myself lucky that I didn’t lose any organs. Celi’s still on a restricted diet while kes new liver grows, but there have been no further complications. Ke’s been cleared for full duty, meaning we have three doctors now. And Captain Sands’ paranoia about the new crew must have been a passing moment of stress, because he’s talking about reviving another group of people.

“We have too many people!” I declare to Adin and Denish while we sit around pretending to get work done in Greenhouse Ring 1. “I liked it when it was just the seven of us. And Captain Sands wasn’t too much of a change. But fourteen people? How are we all supposed to keep track of each other?”

“Well, we have a few years together,” Adin points out. He looks pretty steady, but rubs his hands together fitfully. He’s been doing that a lot since the neurostim detox. “I’m sure that’s plenty of time to get to know each other.”

“We still have group,” Denish assures me, putting his arm around my shoulders. “But a full crew will be good, yes? Less work for each of us, more people to talk to.”

“More people to potentially react badly,” Adin says, tapping his chest over the kill switch to make his point, “but the captain’s been relaxing a lot over time and we have a critical mass of friends now, so I’m not quite so worried about that.”

“Does Heli know?” I ask, remembering her and Adin in Storage Ring 2. That’s not the kind of secret it’s a good idea to keep between a couple.

He blushes and looks away. “Yeah. She does.”

“So you guys have spoken to everyone. Good.”

“We did not speak to Heli,” Denish says, sounding a little surprised.

“She figured it out,” Adin explains. “She had access to a whole bunch of all of our medical files for trying to figure out the genetic engineering thing, remember? She’s seen the kill switches on the X-rays.”

“And she knew what they were?” I ask.

“Yeah. Why?”

I rub my chin. “We already assumed that everyone in what Tiny calls the ‘leadership group’ knew they were going to a colony powered by convict labour. That’s not a great endictment of a person, but it’s not horribly surprising – every country with a prison labour force is complicit in that sort of thing already, it’s something most people just don’t think about. But both Heli and Captain Sands also knew about the kill switches. Cel was in that group, too; someone should ask kem if ke knows about them.”

“You think that everyone in that group knows about the kill switches.”

“Maybe.”

“And that that says worse things about them than just knowing about the convicts.”

“Of course it does.”

Adin cocks his head. “Does it, though?”

“What do you mean, does it? Knowing that you’re in a civilisation that uses convict labour and knowing that you’re in a civilisation that puts kill switches in them in case of disobedience are absolutely two different things! Anyone who would agree to that is – what?!”

The boys are exchanging a glance.

“I think perhaps, Aspen,” Denish says, “you did not think all the way through?”

“What are you talking about?”

“Well,” Adin says, “you worked on Luna for a year, right? Was there any convict labour involved in anything you did?”

“Not really. I mean, the cleaning service that my residence used was convict labour, yeah. Which shocked me a little at first, but you just kind of stop thinking about it after awhile.” I can feel my cheeks getting warm. “I mean, it… it’s hard to get decent temporary accommodation on Luna, you kind of have to take what you can get. And that’s kind of my point; many normal people would make that choice. But if the cleaning service was using kill switches I would’ve said fuck that job and stayed home instead.”

“You sure?” Denish asks.

“What kind of question is – ?!”

“Aspen.” Adin’s voice is neutral, calm. Non-judgemental. “You know that most Lunari convicts are used for dangerous things like mining labour, right? And that most of them die working long before they can finish their sentence?”

“Yeah.”

“So safer, easier work like cleaning homes is in very high demand. Now, in the ‘kill switch’ scenario that you’re imagining, where the threat of death hangs over your cleaning staff if they’re difficult or dangerous enough, that sounds pretty horrifying, I’m sure. But in the actual situation that exists, what do you think happens to them if they’re difficult or dangerous? Or even if they’re just not very good at cleaning? What do you think happens if they look at a snooty client and she takes offense and they get complained about one too many times for being ‘disrespectful’?”

“Mines,” Denish cuts in before I can answer. “Longer, more painful death sentence.”

My face isn’t warm any more. I think most of my blood has left it. “That’s not… I didn’t…”

“That’s not what we’re saying,” Adin says quickly. “We’re not saying there’s anything wrong with moving to Luna for awhile. You’re not responsible for their prison system. We’re saying that, in a situation like this where there is a lot of difficult and dangerous work to be done like, say, terraforming Hylara, the existence of a kill mechanism doesn’t make any appreciable difference. The choice that you just said plenty of normal people make isn’t any different to the one you’re condemning this leadership group for making. Chances are they just didn’t really think about it, same as you didn’t with the cleaning staff. Why would they? Most of them aren’t going to have jobs managing us. They’re just excited for a new home, making a new mark in history.”

“And your plan destroyed our kill switches anyway!” Denish says cheerfully, slapping me on the shoulder and nearly knocking me to the floor. “So do not look sad.”

“Yeah, the question is how we can deactivate the thousands of other convicts’ implants,” I say. “I don’t think we can just dip colonists through the ship’s shielding as they wake up without the captain noticing.”

“We still have years to – ”

“Yeah, we keep saying that, but eventually we’re not going to have years to figure that out any more. Anyway, I still think there’s too many people now. We don’t need a full crew of twenty one just yet, it’s going to get confusing.”

“I like the new people,” Adin says. “Well, mostly.”

If he’s dating Heli, he probably does. I shrug. “The captain should wait another year and let us all get used to each other again. Then the next seven can be a fun novelty for everyone again. Space out the socialisation.”

“You worked at universities, yes?” Denish asks. “In cities? Many people?”

“That’s different. You can have a bunch of casual friends or colleagues or whatever, but a crew has to be different to just casual colleagues.”

“Does it?”

“Well, yeah.”

“You sound like my mum,” Adin says. “How big was your family on Earth? Your, um, your cluster?”

“Uh, nine people, including me. Why?”

“No reason, just curious.” He rubs his hands together again.

“Hey, how are you feeling?” I ask.

“Me? Just fine. Why?”

“It’s just been a lot for you. With the whole genetic engineering thing, and the, the nerve stuff.”

“I’m fine. Plenty of people have much worse damage after taking neurostims.”

“And the genetic engineering?”

He shrugs. “Not much to do about it now, is there? Either it gives us some kind of weird cancer or it doesn’t. Oh, that reminds me; Renn mentioned in passing that he’s put together enough from those journals you found to make a coherent story, and apparently, it’s a lot. He said he’ll be ready to present his findings really soon.”

“He’s almost finished translating? Already?”

“No, he says a lot of it is completely untranslateable. Because of Captain Kinoshita’s unfamiliar shorthand. But what he has is interesting, apparently.”

“I wonder if he’s busy right now…”

“He’s not going to give you a hint. Trust me, I tried.”

“Nobody is any fun on this ship!” I grouse. Just then, the airlock opens, and Tal and Sunset both stumble in. They’re stumbling because they are wearing the highest heeled shoes I’ve ever seen, apparently homemade from our vast supply of indoor slippers and copious quantities of shiny silver tape. (I can’t tell how they made the heels. They’re all covered in tape.) Both of them are giggling, wearing outfits that look to be made of various garish scarves draped over their bodies, and caked in enough bright makeup to make Tal’s tattoos look tame.

“Oh, hey!” Tal points at us. “Makeovers!”

“No,” I say immediately.

“Yes.” They lurch toward us. We all take a step back.

“We can outrun them,” Adin says uncertainly. “They’re clumsy, in those shoes. We can get away, I’m sure.”

“Tal’s pretty fast,” I point out, still backing away. “If we run, it might trigger their prey drive and you’ve seen what Tal can do in full zeelite mode. Maybe we can hide in the plants?”

“In this confined greenhouse ring? No. They’ll find us for sure.”

“You two run,” Denish says in a low voice. “I will distract them.”

“ ‘Nish. No.”

“I will be fine.”

“Denish, they’re going to put so much makeup on you. Look at their nails! They’re sparkling in rainbow stripes!”

“On a ship, one must make sacrifices. I have endured worse. I will be fine. Just run! Run!”

I’m a coward. I run, Adin on my heels. Behind me, I hear Denish greet the zeelites enthusiastically.

“He was a brave man,” Adin notes solemnly as we go through the airlock.

“His sacrifice will be remembered,” I vow.

We stumble into Network and Engineering Ring 1. There’s some kind of conversation happening at the computer terminals; I head over and peek around the petitions to see Renn, Tinera, Lina, and one of the Friends (the non-doctor one) engaged in a game of Lunari checkers. Tinera has a triangular piece of metal dangling from her ear and her scalp is painted in silver geometric patterns.

“The zeelites are in a mood today,” she explains.

“We saw. But you’re the last person I’d expect to give in.”

“They looked really sad when I said no. Want to play?”

“I don’t know the rules,” I admit.

“You spent a year on Luna and didn’t learn how to play Lunari Checkers?”

“I’m not really a board game kind of person. Renn, Adin says you might have something interesting in Kinoshita’s notes?”

“I’ll present my findings with everybody very soon. I just want to double-check a few things with the AI first.”

“Hello, everyone,” Captain Sands greets us, coming around a partition into view. He’s wearing silver eyeshadow and lipstick, and a shiny silver miniskirt. “You have something, Renn?”

“I will very soon, yes. You have nice legs, captain.”

“Why, thank you.”

“How did you let them get you?” I ask. Captain Sands and Tinera?

He shrugs. “Somebody was bound to have an unusual response to all of this recent stress. I’m just happy they aren’t breaking anything. Aspen, I’ll need you to ask them later about where they’re getting their supplies. I doubt this clothing is in our stores so I hope they haven’t cut up anything important.”

“It’s garment broadcloth from the main colony supply,” the Friend says. “This Friend sewed the garments for them.”

“Why?” I ask.

It shrugs. “Because they asked?”

Given how many colonists we’ve lost, we should have a pretty big oversupply of garment broadcloth. I’ll check later to make sure, though.

“Okay,” the captain says, “while I’m here, does anybody have any specific concerns over the next crew revive session?”

“Yeah, we don’t need to revive anyone else right now,” I say.

“This ship will function best with a full crew, and the faster we revive as many CR5 colonists as possible, the better. I meant, do we need any specific types of scientists or anything like that?”

“I don’t think reviving more CR5 colonists saves anyone,” Tinera says. “I mean, we’re not one hundred per cent sure of the details, but everything we’ve got suggests that when the AI thinks it needs another brain, it grabs one, right? And we’re not going to be able to revive everyone at risk. So reviving people at risk takes the danger off them, but increases everyone else’s chance of getting chosen – it doesn’t save anyone, it just picks and chooses who gets taken.”

Captain Sands doesn’t look surprised or confused by this logic. I’m struck with the sudden thought that while CR5 presumably has eighty per cent convicts like everywhere else, all of the captain’s revival choices have been non-convicts. Is this something he’s doing on purpose? Putting convicts at more risk to save more non-convicts?

I shake the thought off. Inventing new things to be suspicious about isn’t helpful.

“On top of that,” I say, “we don’t need a full crew to keep this ship working efficiently. We’re doing just fine now. A bigger crew just puts more strain on the systems. The only reason the crew’s so big in the first place is to protect everyone’s psychological health since it’s such along journey, but given recent circumstances, I think adding more people right now would just cause more stress. Renn, you’re the psychologist; back me up here.”

“I think the full complement of twenty one would be more healthy, psychologically,” Renn says, “but I think you should wait until I’ve finished with Dr Kinoshita’s notes. There is some vitally interesting information that might affect your crew selection.”

Captain Sands’ eyebrows go up. “Really. I look forward to your translation. Well, I’ll start preparing a list, but we’ll wait for Renn’s report first.”

“It’s going to be more fucked up mad science, isn’t it,” Tinera mumbles into her hands.

“There is indeed ‘fucked up mad science’ involved, yes,” Renn says.

Tinera throws her hands up. “Of course there is. We’re out of reach of any human law enforcement so why not just throw the Autonomy Accords out the fucking window? Let’s start genetically engineering people without telling them! Let’s jam a bunch of synnerves into their brains and use them as computer processors! Why not? Next we’ll find out there’s a fucking Lyson project at work on this ship, and if we do, I’m stabbing someone in the neck.” She points to a spot on her own neck. “Right here.”

“The brain hijacking thing is sort of like a Lyson project,” Adin points out.

I shake my head. “Sticking synnerves in someone’s brain is totally different. It’s only a Lyson project if they deliberately kill specific brain tissue to modify human memory, performance, personality or behaviour.”

“There are some truly fascinating Lyson projects out there,” Renn says conversationally. “I’m a great fan of Dr Lyson’s work.”

Everyone is silent for a moment.

“Um,” Adin says. “You mean theoretically, right? Like she made great strides forward in neuroscience, and it’s good to know more about the brain in a theoretical capacity even though we shouldn’t make practical use of it?”

“Well, I think there is some practical use of it to be made. Obviously, it’s a technology with room for abuse, but I think humanity greatly overreacted by banning brain-damage-based behavioural modification almost completely. The existing ‘mad science’ on this ship aside, there are some advantages to be setting up a civilisation beyond the reach of the Autonomy Accords.”

<<First ………. <Prev ………. [Archive] ………. [Map] ………. Next> ………. Last>>

44 thoughts on “074: CULPABILITY

  1. UM. RENN. RENN. I DO NOT LIKE WHAT YOU’RE SAYING THERE MY DUDE. I REALLY, REALLY DO NOT LIKE WHAT YOU’RE SAYING HERE. UM. OF ALL THE PEOPLE I EXPECTED TO BE FUCKED UP THIS WAS NOT ONE OF THEM

    Liked by 3 people

  2. “There are some truly fascinating Lyson projects out there,” Renn says conversationally. “I’m a great fan of Dr Lyson’s work.”
    – well that was an audible yikes

    Liked by 3 people

  3. Well that’s a reassuring thing to hear from your SHIP’S PSYCHOLOGIST jfc. And to think that up until then I worried that Renn was about to be murdered by the AI for knowing too much.

    Liked by 3 people

  4. LMAO i imagine renn just smiling silly while dropping this bombshell that absolutely no one else on the ship (that we know of) agree with

    Liked by 2 people

  5. I have read this so quickly. I love scifi but usually I hate horror. However, this story is so griping that I read it anyway. Did I only get 4hrs of sleep? Sure. Am I up till 1am again? Sure. Am I dying to know whats going on with everything? Of course!

    This has been an excellent read and I can’t wait to explore more of your writing.

    Like

  6. HELLO? IS HE TALKING ABOUT FRIENDS, OR???? Renn dude what the fuck? AND he’s the psych? ooougie would not be suprised if this loses him some team trust.
    Wondering about the logic behind 14 vs 21 people but Idk much about long term small group dynamics.

    Tal and Sunset is a very lovely team up and I think its very cute of them to give everyone makeovers 🙂
    Good stress relief.

    Aspens arm is starting to freak me out though, like,,,, doctor time? Idk, ,,

    Liked by 3 people

  7. Binged the whole story since yesterday and oh my god this is suspenseful and good. I like this vision of the future, dystopian though many parts may be. Thanks so much for writing and sharing this and I’m so curious how it will progress.

    Like

  8. Cute makeovers. Love the helpful friend.

    Oh, dang! I do hope he explains what he means by that. SO EXCITED To hear about the notes though, I’ve been so curious since the moment Aspen found them

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Just binge read this entire story and I LOVE IT. Cannot think, too busy flailing because holy shit!!!! I am obsessed, I need to know more SO BADLY. THE NOTES!! ARE TRANSLATED!!! I NEED TO KNOW WHAT THEY SAY!!!!!

    Like

  10. I discovered this story yesterday and just got up to date, and can I say the title is the most insane Sword of Damocles? Every time one of the characters is like “we’ll be there in four years” or make a calculation based on that assumption, I look at the title and go “no you might not be, that is not necessarily a correct assumption”. Apart from things we can deduce slightly before the characters do (like noticing the difference between the dried and liquid goop in the used stasis pods, or doing math on days in the beginning of the story) the title is the only piece of meta-information that we the readers have that the characters don’t have access too.

    As to Renn’s opinions revealed in this chapter: of course he would think that, Renn’s and captain Sand’s culture gives off extremely eugenicist vibes, this opinion on non-consensually fucking with other people’s brains for “the greater good” is very aligned with that set of values. Big yikes for everyone else on board I gotta say, it makes both of them extremely untrustworthy – especially long term – even if the crew does need their skills short term.

    Liked by 5 people

  11. Renn no. If you can’t be a decent human being at least read the fucking room.
    Really exceptional (derogatory) take for the ship psychologist to have.

    Liked by 2 people

  12. There’s certainly a lot of deeply contentious ethics conundrums at play here, aren’t there? Sands assumes everyone who’s a convict is some horrible person; Aspen assumes everyone who knows about the kill switches and still agreed to this are horrible people. The Friends both underwent voluntary neurosurgery to make themselves “less selfish,” which wouldn’t necessarily be sinister except that they’ve been called a cult plenty and those can involve lots of corruption, coercion and brainwashing type stuff. Adin entertained the notion he’s a better person than Tinera because he, a drug dealer, “didn’t kill anyone” and she (confirmed to have murdered… at least one person, but possibly only one and “they deserved it,” though we only have her assurance on that) did. We’ve got non-consensual genetic engineering, Renn thinks the setting’s Geneva Convention equivalent is something potentially good to be rid of, Lina apparently did something pretty concerning from a medical ethics standpoint (or Sands thinks so)… I, for one, find all this nuance extremely compelling. Who’s to say all of them aren’t roughly equal amounts of sort-of-horrible and sort-of-good… a lot like pretty much everyone in real life, a complicated mess. Oh, and let’s not forget about Amy, who as an AI doesn’t possess the capacity for morality at all, unless of course she does because we know the absolute least about her of any character.

    Anyway, I cannot tell you how much I completely lost it when Captain Sands walked in in a miniskirt.

    Liked by 4 people

    1. FWIW, it seems pretty clear to me that the Friends are only called a cult because they’re super weird, and people at large make little to no effort to distinguish between “weirdos being weird” and “actual abuse.”

      Like

  13. Oh no….. Rennnnnnnnnn……. I KNEW you were sus.

    Also, I’m kinda surprised Sands let the Tal et al dress him up. He seems to be….. a lot more human and sympathetic lately. Also, we never found out *why* he was only on the project for six months.

    Also also, Aspen, honey, you’re not fooling anyone. You feel like your original crew is your replacement cluster and don’t want anyone new to join bc then that adds people outside your “family” into the mix. 😦 Too bad we don’t have a non-crazy therapist for you to work through this with.

    Liked by 5 people

  14. what a terrifically ominous place to end this chapter!

    loved that little commentary from Adin and Denish on the convict labor system. love that they’re gentle, because Aspen truly isn’t at fault for any of this, but….well, good chapter title.

    also, love the zeelite makeover brigade, good for them

    Like

  15. I’m a little worried about Aspen’s arm. The shield killed everyone in the old crew’s symnerves except theirs- could the weirdly extensive nerve system be still active somehow?

    Liked by 1 person

  16. Renn is actually sortof reasonable here, because it does sound like the worlds overreacted to the problems with that field of study. They even outlaw genetic modification for embryos, which just locks out a whole lot of room for improving people!
    Though I kinda expect this to turn into people being paranoid about Renn.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hopefully, Renn only thinks that the consensual brain modification ban should be reverted, and doesn’t actually want *government* fucking with convicts’ or asylum inmates’ brains. In that case, I definitely agree with him (kem? them? I don’t remember Renn’s gender, lol). But the phrasing could *definitely* be worked on, and being a professional psychologist, Renn *should* know better than to say things like that.

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Sometimes you’ve got a hot take so hot that you just don’t want to cool it down. I think that, as a professional psychologist, Renn used their training to find the maximally funny way to drop this fact.

        I mean, there’s been an opportunity to say something for weeks. Renn was absolutely sitting on this.

        Like

  17. “There are some truly fascinating Lyson projects out there,” Renn says conversationally. “I’m a great fan of Dr Lyson’s work.”

    The way I started laughing the way I started LAUGHING

    Liked by 1 person

  18. I knew it… i KNEW I felt bad vibes about him being a behavioralist. Don’t deal with and care for people as they are, just change their personalities so they’re easier to deal with. Fuck this guy.

    Liked by 1 person

  19. I love the story although not commenting much. But here I need to comment that I bet Aspen got injected by the missing stuff into his “bad sleep” arm and he deserves all that’s no doubt coming for not telling anyone about the sudden weird feeling in his arm 😀

    Also did I miss it somewhere or did really no one check the engine defect that’s supposed to be unrepairable? Not like the guy saying so could be a part of the conspiracy and lie about it, right? 👀

    Liked by 1 person

  20. i have a feeling that Heli is manipulating Adin… The way that she knew about the kill switches and figured out they were deactivated is giving me a bad gut feeling, we know she interacts less with the crew, plus she’s a doctor so she could use information about adin’s neurostim addiction or SOMETHING. And how Adin was emphasised to be timid right next to his intimate scene with her… Easy target for manipulation. I hope I’m wrong though, like maybe she doesn’t want that slave labour colony/unethical experiments XD plus i might be misremembering details!

    Liked by 1 person

  21. literally said “UUUHHH??” out loud far too loud when I read Renn’s last lines there, you know I was just thinking how he reminds me of Maruki from Persona 5 Royal, now I guess he gets to join the “truly awful therapists” club

    Like

  22. i know the big WHAM moment in this chapter is Renn’s opinion on lobotomizing people “for their own good”, but I notice that Aspen’s opinion on “what they would have done had they known about a kill switch on Luna” has changed since it was last brought up. Last time they said they would have thought it was fucked up and protested but still gone to work, and that was with the assumption that they personally were given a command for the kill switch. Now they’re saying they would have noped out of Luna.

    Liked by 3 people

  23. “if one night of wrong sleep can hurt my arm for days”
    it can’t and didn’t, it’s gotta be something else

    “They’re stumbling because they are wearing the highest heeled shoes I’ve ever seen”
    Good! For! Them!

    “”We can outrun them,” Adin says uncertainly. “They’re clumsy, in those shoes.””
    heeeeee!

    ““You two run,” Denish says in a low voice. “I will distract them.””
    So funny

    “He’s wearing silver eyeshadow and lipstick, and a shiny silver miniskirt.”
    omg? 😳

    “I’m a great fan of Dr Lyson’s work.”
    Of course you are, you fucking behaviorist creep

    Liked by 1 person

  24. being a usamerican and seeing people who can choose where they live willingly moving to a place that relies on unpaid/underpaid convict labor — slavery — like the united states (or luna, or hylara) does is wild. if I could I would simply not live in a slave state

    also I was warily reserving judgment on renn because of how little information he revealed about himself, but good LORD did the other shoe drop

    Liked by 1 person

  25. oh no, aspen is forced to confront the fact that they might have done something Problematic.

    I like the Friends and the Friends are just barely on this side of not getting outlawed for being Lyson-lite, so Renn is probably based and I would like to subscribe to his newsletter.

    Like

Leave a reply to StarryEyedMeander Cancel reply